
I have very little perspective and therefore very little opinion on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. Personally, I don’t understand why these two cultures can’t coexist. They’ve locked themselves into a cycle of mutual violent reprisals, and I wonder if that cycle will ever be broken.
What I do know is that Steven Spielberg has caught flack from both Palestinian and Israeli sympathizers for his new film, “Munich”. That usually means story in question is pretty fair.
Basically, after a group of Palestinian terrorists kidnap and murder several Israeli athletes during the 1972 Olympics, Israel sends a secret revenge squad consisting of 5 guys to travel around Europe and kill 11 people believed responsible for planning the Munich murders. Their leader is Avner, played by Eric Bana. (He gets angry in the movie, and I kept expecting him to turn green, but that’s a different story.)
The story unfolds from the point of view of the Israeli hit squad, but it is sympathetic to neither side, and to both. Avner and his crew are committed to the cause, but they seem to be only barely capable. They wouldn’t last long in an “Ocean’s 11″ movie. They have problems, their equipment fails, they miscalculate and they overcompensate. Avner is also a new father, and nervous about his job. Each of the crew struggles with the morality of what they are doing, and whether or not they are actually accomplishing anything.
In my opinion, the revenge squad was about hate and pride, and not about Israel protecting its citizens. Each side of the conflict seems to believe that they must convince “the world” that they are right, or at least that they won’t be bullied around. This is why attacks are planned to have high publicity, and why the hit squad uses bombs instead of guns. They want people to know what they’re doing. (Which was strange since Israel went to great lengths to disconnect itself from the hit squad.)
The movie ends with a shot of downtown Manhattan from Brooklyn, and the World Trade Center towers are plainly visible. They were built the same year that the Munich murders took place, and were the tallest buildings in the world from ‘72 to ‘73. (It is strange that after 9/11 filmmakers rushed to remove such shots from movies, and now they add them.) Their presence of course underscores the connection between our own national security problems and those in the cradle of civilization. America has become a target for terrorism primarily for our involvement in the Middle East, and a large part of that hatred stems from our unconditional support of Israel.
In the film, Israeli prime minister Golda Meir (played by Lynn Cohen) justifies the revenge squad when she says “Every civilization finds it necessary to negotiate compromises with its own values.”
Spielberg is asking us to consider what values our own government has compromised in dealing with terrorism at home and abroad. Avner questions the rightness of his actions by the end of the film. I have to wonder if U.S. military personnel around the world often ask the same questions.
Latest Comments
RSS